I'm not sure it would really be appropriate for Broadway. It was pretty much just a special effects extravaganza with a loose plot to sort of tie everything together. If it was staged exactly as it was in Las Vegas with the animatronic dragons that came up from the stage floor then there probably wouldn't be a theatre on Broadway big enough to house it. I'm pretty sure the theatre at the MGM Grand was built specifically for that show.
It also went through several changes over the years, and the show began to really lose focus toward the end. The Michael Crawford version was definitely the most coherent, and there were some good songs. I really like "Tonight," "Greatest Showman in the Universe" and the title song.
The recordings with David Cassidy and Tommy Tune document the deterioration of what little plot there was to start with. By the time Rick Springfield joined the cast most of the original score was gone and they didn't even bother recording it again, but I'm pretty sure they did film the final performance and it was available as a limited edition on Rick Springfield's website.
Broadway Legend Joined: 5/28/05
It is, or rather was, a fun show to look at. There were a couple descent songs in it, but it would never work on Broadway and will likely never be seen again. Cats probably had more of a plot holding its scenes together than EFX did.
It was really the special effects and Crawford's showmanship that made the original incarnation worth watching. It is my understanding that after he left it just kept going down hill.
Videos