#1
Posted: 9/20/06 at 10:45pm
Dear Moderators who are not named Moderator. I will not speak for the community of members here, but I speak for what I think is best for the community. I will refrain from using derogatory terms and from name calling because I want to this thread to be read in a serious and thoughtful way (plus I have been threatened with banning if I use the terms I have used in previously deleted threads). This thread will probably be deleted, and I will probably be banned, but hopefully not before a few members, that clearly have more clout than I, read it. I feel that we, as a community that are under some sort of observation and for lack of a better term, control, with what we can post that we deserve to know the identity of the nameless Moderator. I say this because I honestly believe that the power is either being used inappropriately and abused, or that perhaps, the more likely case, that we need more that this one Moderator, but in public view. There must be some sort of system of checks and balances. What is to stop our nameless authoritarian (not an insult, simply a name for someone who has the power) from possibly abusing the power if there is no accountability? I have had several exchanges with the nameless Moderator today, mainly because I felt I was being treated unfairly. Did I go too far? Probably, but when we as a group have no recourse, no way to bring up our complaints without the threat of deletion because the person we would like to complain about seems to be the only one with any power, how else can we handle it but to make a public scene and hope as many people see it before it gets deleted as possible? Two things led to the escalation of my actions. First, I had multiple threads deleted for apparently violating the YouTube Guideline. However, when I read the guideline nothing in my threads was in violation. Second, the nameless Moderator refused to answer why. Even when I explained that they did not violate the guideline I was given no response. While most of the PMs I sent to the nameless Moderator were heated I refrained from vulgarities, but did on multiple occasions use the terms "Stalin," "Stalinist" and "KGB." These were also not met with any response beyond deletion of more threads and finally the threat of banning if the comparisons and name calling continued. This (at least near the end of the ordeal, including the threat of banning) occurred all while a member was running rampant in a thread posting disturbing, disgusting, vulgar and pornographic images (for which a thread calling for Craig to take some action had been created). The nameless moderator decided that it was a more pressing matter to delete my thread calling attention to the fact that innocuous threads I had created earlier in the day had been deleted and now when something that was actually threatening to the board and disruptive to the board was occurring, no action was being taken (with a claim of having no knowledge of such abusive posts despite the aforementioned thread calling for action from Craig and my threads also calling attention to the events that were deleted). If asked, I will gladly post any and all PM's I sent related to the matter. But I just wanted to get this out there.
I want to stress once more (because 1, I am being completely honest in my attempt here, and 2, I really don't want to see this thread deleted and myself banned because I truly enjoy posting here), that this is not meant as an attack, it is a question, a request, a pleading for answers, for information (because such pleas, even in peaceful PMs have been ignored). I believe we, as a community have a right to know who it is at the reins of the power to make threads disappear. If not just for curiosity's sake, so there can be some accountability for those with the power. Because, as trite and clichéd as it may be, who will watch the watchers?
Respectfully,
ZONEACE AKA Chance Hamlin
I want to stress once more (because 1, I am being completely honest in my attempt here, and 2, I really don't want to see this thread deleted and myself banned because I truly enjoy posting here), that this is not meant as an attack, it is a question, a request, a pleading for answers, for information (because such pleas, even in peaceful PMs have been ignored). I believe we, as a community have a right to know who it is at the reins of the power to make threads disappear. If not just for curiosity's sake, so there can be some accountability for those with the power. Because, as trite and clichéd as it may be, who will watch the watchers?
Respectfully,
ZONEACE AKA Chance Hamlin
when ducks grow thumbs then maybe my opinion will change.