I would vote for Dench over Mirren as well.
But three things work against Dench. She is playing a dislikeable, deeply disturbing role... and you can count on one hand the number of times a dislikeable, disturbing, (borderline) "villainous" leading lady has won a Best Actress Oscar. I can only think of three ever, but there may be one or two more: Louise Fletcher, Kathy Bates and Charlise Theron. The Best Actress award usually goes to a "noble" character who sacrifices something for the greater good, whether on a large scale or small. She gives of herself in order to get something far more lasting and meaningful. That's what usually wins a Best Actress Oscar. Helen fits the bill. Dench does not.
Also, Dench has won an Oscar. Helen has not. The Academy remembers things like that.
And three, The Queen is a much better movie than Notes on a Scandal, which is brilliant up until the last 15 minutes, when it inexplicably "slams into a wall" and feels terribly edited and incomplete. I have no idea what happened there, but the last act is very strangely constructed and it undermines the whole movie, sadly.
Still I would vote for Dench this year, because that performance was more difficult to pull off than Mirren's work in The Queen. Mirren was terrific, but not nearly as challenged as an actress in this particular case. Dench's work has the "wow" factor, big-time.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22
Updated On: 2/5/07 at 11:00 AM