it's another of those games everyone likes. one vote per person per day, and maybe supply some reasoning behind your pick.
which one of these geniuses is your favorite?
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (10)
Hello Again, The Wild Party, First Lady Suite, Marie Christine, See What I Wanna See, Little Fish
JASON ROBERT BROWN (10)
Parade, The Last Five Years, Songs for a New World, Urban Cowboy
ADAM GUETTEL (10)
Floyd Collins, Myths and Hymns, The Light in the Piazza, The Princess Bride
RICKY IAN GORDON (10)
Bright Eyed Joy, My Life with Albertine, Only Heaven, Dream True
i love LaChuisa's style and intricacies, "Marie Christine" is a fave of mine.
Jason Robert Brown's "The Last Five Years" is some genius on stage.
and Adam Guettel, he's got the heritage and the talent to back up his wonderful work so far.
but overall I pick LACHUISA!
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (11) +
JASON ROBERT BROWN (10)
ADAM GUETTEL (10)
RICKY IAN GORDON (9) -
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (11) +
JASON ROBERT BROWN (10)
ADAM GUETTEL (11)+
RICKY IAN GORDON (
-
Broadway Legend Joined: 1/3/05
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (11)
JASON ROBERT BROWN (11)+
ADAM GUETTEL (11)+
RICKY IAN GORDON (7)-
Edited to supply reasoning: Jason Robert Brown is an absolute genius. I cannot listen to his stuff enough! The Last 5 Years and Songs for a New World are two of my favorite shows of all time. I also love MJL so he was a close second.
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/3/04
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12) +
JASON ROBERT BROWN (11)
ADAM GUETTEL (11)+
RICKY IAN GORDON (6)-
Featured Actor Joined: 7/12/04
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12)
JASON ROBERT BROWN (10) -
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (7) +
Ya'll don't give Ricky Ian Gordon enough credit! His work is pretty amazing, my favorite being Only Heaven. Hearing Darius deHaas sing "Heaven" is amazing, and "Daybreak In Alabama" is one of my favorite songs of all time.
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12)
JASON ROBERT BROWN (11)
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (6)
Brown is simply the best
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12)
JASON ROBERT BROWN (12) +
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (5) -
No question of the four Brown is my favorite -- The Last Five Years would have been enough (dayenu), but Parade, Songs for a New World...and Someone To Fall Back On! Nothing against Guettel or LaChuisa - and if The Princess Bride is great, Guettel will REALLY give Brown a run for his money, but for now, Brown wins. I never got into Gordon's work.
JASON ROBERT BROWN (13) +
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12)
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (4) -
The Last 5 Years brings me to tears nearly every time that I listen to it. The only Gordon that I am familiar with is My Life with Albertine which I only hear songs from on accuradio, and these don't ever make me want to listen to the whole show.
Each of these men is certainly tremendously talented though.
JASON ROBERT BROWN (14) +
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (12)
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (3) -
Featured Actor Joined: 7/12/04
JASON ROBERT BROWN (13) -
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA (13) +
ADAM GUETTEL (11)
RICKY IAN GORDON (3)
JASON ROBERT BROWN 13
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA 14 (+)
ADAM GUETTEL 13
RICKY IAN GORDON 2 (-)
Broadway Legend Joined: 9/3/04
JASON ROBERT BROWN 13
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA 15 (+)
ADAM GUETTEL 13
RICKY IAN GORDON 1 (-)
JASON ROBERT BROWN 13
MICHAEL JOHN LACHUISA 15
ADAM GUETTEL 14 (+)
RICKY IAN GORDON 0 (-)
Broadway Legend Joined: 8/12/04
JASON ROBERT BROWN 12 (-)
MICHAEL JOHN LACHIUSA 15
ADAM GUETTEL 15 (+)
JASON ROBERT BROWN 13 (+)
MICHAEL JOHN LACHIUSA 14 (-)
ADAM GUETTEL 15
Broadway Legend Joined: 11/2/05
JASON ROBERT BROWN 12 -
MICHAEL JOHN LACHIUSA 14
ADAM GUETTEL 16 +
The only thing I find more tiresome that Mr. Brown's music is the man himself.
Videos