OK, so, yes, Islam is far more extreme at its extremes at this point in time than Christianity. Right.
And, therefore we should....?
What, equate ISIS with Islam? Not try to politically distance ISIS from Islam in order to appeal to Muslims in order to enjoin them in a fight against ISIS? Use this particular point in history to condemn Islamic governments or Islamic practices wholesale, including the extremist Islamic regime of our Saudi allies, and just take on ISIS with no help from Muslim cooperatives - Would that be a politically wise thing to do? Would that benefit the effort to defeat ISIS? How exactly would that work?
Stalin was a totalitarian and responsible for the murder of millions of people well before and during World War II. Hitler was also a totalitarian. It was the age of totalitarianism. It was brutal.
But in order to defeat Nazi totalitarianism we didn't succeed by broadly broadcasting our disfavor of totalitarianism; we joined with one totalitarian to defeat another. And, as it happens, the world is a far better place because we did. Far from perfect, still fraught with horrors, but certainly far better.
Just how great would the Greatest Generation have been in its aims if not for their having Soviet colleagues in destroying Hitler?
By the way nothing in this post should be taken as suggesting that I favor military intervention to defeat ISIS. I have big reservations that doing so is not going to make things better for the region; but I certainly consider the objective of defeating ISIS imperative, haven't completely ruled out military intervention as an unjustified or misguided alternative, and, above all, don't think any effort to defeat ISIS can be accomplished by linking ISIS with Islam or even by failing to distance Islam from ISIS.
Jesus is a prophet of Islam. Jesus said that the greatest commandment was to love thy neighbors as thyself. Raping, kidnapping, enslaving and beheading ones neighbors is not following the greatest commandment of jesus, one of the three prophets of islam. It is violating it. Therefore, the statement that ISIS is not Islam is not without merit. Nor is it without merit to say that all the travesties committed by Christians in the name of Christianity which violated this greatest commandment were unChristian. And that includes things being done by Christians today, and in the name of religion, which although a far cry from what ISIS is doing are still horrible.
Updated On: 9/30/14 at 12:05 PM