Thanks for the response, WOSQ!
My travel dates are fixed and soon -- the end of this month into the beginning of February -- but I appreciate the IGLA suggestion! If I were more activity-driven, I'd consider it. I'm more the eat-in-restaurants, stroll-the-streets, gape-at-geography, drink-in-bars type of vacationer.
Your friends have said 5 days is plenty, and, yes, that is definitely my concern. Not that it wouldn't just be nice to relax away from home, but I don't want to get restless and still have four days to go. You mentioned the London stopover. I've been trying multi-destination options on sites like Travelocity and Priceline, including PIT-REK-LON, but it only turns up insanely expensive options. At your mention, I just went directly to the Icelandic Air website and looked at their London page, and while it allows for the booking, I still can't find anything about a London leg being included in the price of a round-trip from Reykjavik to the States or, even a deal that's under the cost of two separate round-trip tickets.
But a London pop-over is something I'm very interested in. Do you have any more details on this? Feel free to take it to PM if you'd like!
CHURCH DOOR TOUCAN GAY MARKETING PUPPIES MUSICAL THEATER STAPLES PERIOD OIL BITCHY SNARK HOLES