I had a fabulous social studies lesson today. I got it from the internet to adapt, so I'm not claiming it as my own, but it really hit home with my kids. I teach a class of 2nd graders, all African American. Today before SS, I gave them all a sticker. Then I went to sit in our library with five cushions set out in front of me. As the students came over, those with pink stickers (though I did not tell them why) got to sit on the cushions while the other 20 students were not allowed to sit there. I let the "pink" students go get water and come back, and when the other students asked why I said "that's the way it is." Then I did a read-aloud about MLK, Jr. I only asked the students on the cushions how they liked the story, etc. I let them talk out of turn but refused to call on the students in the back, etc. I was torn between feeling horrible for treating them unfairly (it was truly heartrending at times) to being slightly amused at how big a deal it was (and the looks of sheer anger on some of my kids' faces).
The point of the lesson, as you can imagine, was for the students to feel what prejudice felt like (to some degree). By the end of the lesson, when a student in the back tried to say something, someone else would say "she's not gonna call on you, she only cares about them." When the book was over, I asked why they think we might have done this. My students really got the connection--very exciting for second grade! The message really hit home. It also allowed the students who did experience privilege to say what they experienced--they liked being treated well, and while they still thought it was unfair, they didn't speak up because they didn't want to risk not getting to do the same things. An excellent lesson, and with the right modifications, would certainly work at any age.
Oh, and I let all the students go get drinks after--for the record.
Why do we play with fire?
Why do we run our fingers through the flame?
Why do we leave our hands on the stove, although we know we're in for some pain?
-tick...tick...BOOM!