The Official Adam Pascal Love Thread, part five — Page 180

I think Spike Lee probably would've made a much darker, dirtier movie. BUT, if his casting was so ridiculous...

What I don't understand is why he went so far with Justin, if he was also looking at people like Raúl, Orfeh and Audra. They're serious actors. He's not.

Granted, I think I would've had a serious problem with someone with no Broadway ties playing Roger, even if it weren't Adam.

I used to say things like... that I didn't know whose right it was to mess with Jonathan's work; but do any of us know what he would want?

---

Do any of us know what he would want?

No, but, if Spike Lee had directed the movie with people like Justin and Beyonce, etc., regardless of how hard they worked on it, I would feel like it was some sort of betrayal or mockery of Jonathan's vision. It's just not the same.

---

I've seen Spike Lee, Baz Luhrmann, Rob Marshall, Sam Mendes and Martin Scorcese all discussed. Spike Lee has his own very pointed agenda in all his films. He might have made an interesting movie, but there probably wouldn't have been much of Rent in it. Baz Luhrmann's style is so over the top that all his characters feel like puppets, not people. His films are fun but have little emotional connection of the kind that Rent demands. Rob Marshall would have been somewhat the same, I feel, in a less pronounced way. He's style over substance too. I have a lot of respect for Sam Mendes, but his emotional temperament is the polar opposite of Larson's. His best subject is probably alienation, not connection. Martin Scorcese seems like the only real possibility, and apparently he came to the conclusion that he couldn't find a way to do it. Aside from that, spectacle seems to be overtaking emotion in his work, and it has some of the same chilly remoteness as Mendes'.

Sorry to go into all this detail, but I work in film and have thought about it a lot.

Updated On: 2/5/06 at 07:25 PM

Katt, don't submit it. It's not really a secret, it's just an inside joke. And after last week's, this thread doesn't need anymore attention

---

Yeah, it probably doesn't, lol. I don't think I'm going to submit it.

Sam Mendes is brilliant, no doubt about it, but as I said, probably would not have been as nearly in tune with the emotion in the show. Sweeney Todd, on the other hand, seems perfect for him and I'm sorry that he apparently won't be doing it now.

If those people were in rENT I would not watch it.

---

Justin replacing Adam? ew

---

I'm still slightly astonished by the idea that Spike Lee wanted Justin Timberlake to play Roger. I just can't see the thought process behind that.

---

It's called $$.

---

Silly girls - he is MARRIED to a writer. Why didn't we think of that angle?!!? :)

And if Spike Lee wanted to draw people in by casting a celebrity, he could have easily done it with a character who wasn't as central to the story, like, I don't know, Usher as Benny or something.

---