I understand the disappointment. This film cannot be remotely catagorized as a horror movie. The trailer, the print ads, the use of "warning" rhetoric in an elaborate ritualistic lingo, everything about it suggests a cross between Shirley Jackson's THE LOTTERY and a BLAIR WITCH prequel (to be fair,in one brief sequence, it does have a few moments of homage to the blair witch technique, no?) But I liked it, and didn't mind where it ultimately lands. Without spoiling it, to me the movie is a powerful parable, with some complex bigger themes: using fear to control, and what is the price of creating a utopia. I guessed both of the "twists," though to be fair, they aren't twists, but explanations of a very intricate backstory. And M. Night plays fair throughout--things that look like red herrings, from the first moment, are very tied to the revelations. I don't think the horror crowd -- or even the suspense genre folk -- will embrace it, and kids, in particular, will be mighty pissed off. It is miles away from SIGNS and 6th SENSE in tone and in imagery. Ironically, those who will appreciate its TWILIGHT ZONE parable aspects might stay away. Too bad; there's a lot to chew on.
I saw MANCHURIAN today, and think it and THE VILLAGE are interesting companion pieces about these difficult times. MANCHURIAN is of course a far wilder ride. Good weekend--both movies are "popcorn" type, but adult, and intelligent. I'll take 'em over ham sandwich stuff like DAY AFTER TOMORROW, which barely made sense and existed only for CGI post-production opps. These are real stories, and for grown-ups.
"I'm a comedian, but in my spare time, things bother me." Garry Shandling
Updated On: 7/31/04 at 06:47 PM