"Ya know...?
I wasn't as moved or nostalgically tearful as I'd hoped. I expected the kind of send-off that MTM, M*A*S*H, Newhart, etc. had (as posted in another thread).
When I compare how well-written and moving other
Office "send-off" episodes have been (i.e., Michael's good-bye episode, Michael's proposal to Holly, and others), this finale fell pretty short.
*******
SPOILERS (IF YOU HAVEN"T SEEN THE FINALE YET, YOU MIGHT WANT TO STOP READING) ******
This finale felt very "cut and paste". It seemed that there were too many loose ends that needed to be un-cohesively tossed together like a salad, just so that they could
finally be resolved.
Some elements should have been taken care of in recent weeks. (IMO, there was a lot of wasted "filler" time towards the end.) For example, I think Pam should have sold the house and completely resolved the Jim/Pam storyline last week. No need to drag it out for this finale. That way, "finale" time could have been completely devoted to making me cry...
Although it was fun to see Meredeth's son show up as the stripper, why ONLY him when there were so many other memorable, minor characters who might
also have been inventively included to "surprise" and emphasize 9 years of nostalgia? I'm sure it would have been difficult to write, but to have David show up in the finale, but not Jan was weird.
There was also an odd imbalance of "fiction" (the wedding) and "disguised reality" plot elements (those fabulous lines that were written for characters once they all finally got back to the office set). BTW, that physical move from wedding reception back to the office was *really* clunky and forced. Oh, and call me crazy, but I didn't like seeing Angela so happy and reasonable.
There were a few really GREAT moments (we all know what they were 'cause they've already been mentioned), but this was not the finale it COULD have been. A wedding reception seems like the perfect setting for reunion, reminiscing, and nostalgia. That didn't happen, though - at least not as well as it should have. This finale seemed un-focused and pasted together.
I enjoyed the 1-hour retrospective that came before the final episode much more than the actual finale.
Updated On: 5/17/13 at 01:43 PM