Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

As some of you may know, my dad passed away this past September. Well, my sister came over to my house tonight and said they found this box of letters that my dad wrote to my mom. They were written in 1954, a few months before their wedding- leading up to their wedding. Anyway, my sister put all of these letters in a book form and gave me the book tonight. Although I am curious, I feel like this is an invasion of privacy. If my mom had wanted me to read them, she would have given them to me years ago-she passed away almost 18 years ago. Am I being overly sensitive? My sister let her daughter have this book and she even gave a copy to my daughter. She said when you read it- you will cry. She said everyone who has read it has cried. I told her I would look at it later. I think she was expecting more of a reaction from me but I just can't help feeling like these were private moments for my parents. It's amazing that my mom kept all of them. What do you all think? (and thanks for indulging me on this and taking the time to read the post)
#2

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

I don't consider this an invasion of privacy. Your parents obviously loved each other very much and for your Mother to keep the letters all these years means they obviously held a special place in her heart and she did not want to discard them. I'd like to think she would be pleased they're still going to live on in your family as a memory of the love your parents had for each other.

I think it's beautiful, really.
#3

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Mom. my Dad just passed on Dec 6th at 82. When I was collecting some papers from his house I found his strongbox under his bed. In it were three letters he had written his dad from the Korean war when he was 16. I read them, They were heart rending! A young boy who joined the army to impress his Dad... My Grandfather never responded to those letters. So much was learned and finally understood from my reading the
Those Blocked: SueStorm. N2N Nate. Good riddence to stupid! Rad-Z, shill begone!
#4

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Sounds like your sister put alot of heart and effort into creating a beautiful keepsake by creating a book out of the letters.

I can only imagine that she felt disappointed that she didn't get a reaction of gratitude for her efforts - which were surely heartfelt.

Whether you read them or not, sounds like you didn't show the gratitude your sister deserved for giving you a gift from the heart.
"Two drifters off to see the world. There's such a lot of world to see. . ."
#5

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Thanks everyone! There's a lot more to the family dynamics that I won't go into. NYadgal-when my sister gave me the book- it was in front of my husband, daughter, and some of my daughter's friends who were over working on a school project. It was a little awkward and it's not like I could read it right then. I didn't know what to say at the time. Also- I'm not one to demonstrate my feelings publically. All I remember about my parents is how much they bickered and perhaps these letters will give me more insight as to who they were. I think I'm going to have to work up to that though. Thanks for all of your words and your time! Snafu- thanks for sharing your story.
#7

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

It seems to me, with the variables that you're choosing to withhold or disclose, that you're looking for a certain response to this. What is it you want to hear?

Here's what I think:

Burn the book and never speak to your sister again. Why is she trying to show you up -- again! -- in front of everybody????

Is that it?
Twitter @NamoInExile Instagram none
#8

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Only you can decide how you feel about them- I'd read them, but if it doesn't seem right to you, throw it out, or put it up in the closet or whatever.
#9

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Maybe one day you'll be ready, but it sounds like you're clearly not ready to read them now. That's fair enough.

You can always read the first and make a judgement call from there to read the rest.
#10

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Your sister's intentions were good, but it's a rather strange idea. I'd be very uncomfortable with reading someone else's love letters, and putting them in book form is a bit much.
#11

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

I agree with Urban. Clearly, you're not emotionally ready to read them, which is perfectly understandable. But, let me ask this question: Do you think your parents would want you to read them?
"If this is going to be a Christian nation that doesn't help the poor, either we have to pretend that Jesus was just as selfish as we are, or we've got to acknowledge that He commanded us to love the poor and serve the needy without condition and then admit that we just don't want to do it." -Stephen Colbert
#12

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Namo- thanks for your response but the answer to your question is NO!-I'm not that dramatic! My response was more like nygirl232's. Topher- knowing my mom- I think she would be mortified that others were reading these letters, let alone putting them in a book for all to read. (she got upset when my mother-in-law tried to get me to call her mom- which I never could because I had a mom) It's not about being emotionally ready, it's about wanting my parents private memories that they shared before any of us were born to remain private. I came to the board because I value all of your opinons. I wasn't sure if I was being overly sensitive about this or if I was totally off. So thanks again everyone for your time and thoughts! I really appreciate it!
#13

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

If you can't read them to yourself perhaps your son could read them to you; you said he is an actor, right? And I imagine he is close to the age your dad was when he wrote them. It might be like hearing your dad's voice...

If all you remember is them bickering, it seems to me your mom kept them so she and the rest of the family could know that there was a time that they really loved each other.

Your sister sounds like an amazing person, too.
PEACE.
#14

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Sueleen- I was wondering when this thread would start to turn-lol! My son is 18, my dad was 29 when the letters were written. I can just see the look on my son't face when I ask him to read these- Priceless. It's funny- my son looks a lot like my dad did and his personality is very similar to his. I guess that generation skipping thing is true. Your post made me smile though and I like what you said in the second paragraph! Considering that my parents moved so many times and even spent time in Guam- it's amazing that the letters made it through all the moves and years! Thanks for your thoughts- the 2nd paragraph that is!
#15

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Having them in hand, would you really NOT read them? The question, more honestly, seems to be whether to read them and admit that you did.

The people in question are gone. They aren't going to be hurt by whatever you do.
Sueleen Gay: "Here you go, Bitch, now go make some fukcing lemonade." 10/28/10
#16

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

My family recently went through the death of both my grandmother and grandfather. While we were cleaning the house (months later)we came across the letters he wrote her while they were courting (his word). They revealed a side of my grandfather that nobody knew and gave us such an insight into their relationship.

If your mother kept the letters it is because she truly cared about them. Maybe Sueleen is right, and they reminded her of happier times. While I don't think now is the right time for you to read them, based on what you have posted here, I do think you should save the book and read it when the time is right.
David walked into the valley With a stone clutched in his hand He was only a boy But he knew someone must take a stand There will always be a valley Always mountains one must scale There will always be perilous waters Which someone must sail -Into the Fire Scarlet Pimpernel
#19

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

I think the letters were left for you read or they would have been destroyed long ago...
The great thing with human brains is they're fanless, nice and quiet although I'm sure mine whistles a bit sometimes.
#20

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Thanks Dolly! I was looking for objective thoughts- not subjective. This was a good place to ask because the other posters gave me insights that I hadn't thought about! Also, I was hoping someone would have had a similar experience and some did. So no- I don't find it strange at all that others helped me make up my mind. I will probably read the book in spurts though!
#23

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Just a word of advice. If they start using phrases like: Dirty Sanchez or Rusty Trombone stop reading immediately. Just forward them to me.
Those Blocked: SueStorm. N2N Nate. Good riddence to stupid! Rad-Z, shill begone!
#24

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

Oh, you must!

After my mother died and my father remarried, he sent my sister boxes and boxes of things he didn't want to throw away but didn't want to keep around. She found a picture my mother had inscribed to my father with the words "Love always, Harriet."

After my father died, my sister scanned it and emailed it toi me. Now I have a beautiful picture of mother, seeming to wish me love...always.

I'm sure your mother would have wanted you to read the letters. If not, she could have burned them or thrown them out. But they survived and they are a tribute to their love. I'm sure once you read them, you will feel lucky to have them.

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?


#25

Torn- Should I read my dad's love letters to my mom?

I agree with PJ^^^


A few years ago, my mother gave me evry condolence card that was sent to my Grandmother, after my Grandfather had passed away. I found that really strange.

And after reading them, I realized that everyone really loved my Grandfather.

My Grandmother, not so much...

I ended up burning them.
"TheatreDiva90016 - another good reason to frequent these boards less."<<>> “I hesitate to give this line of discussion the validation it so desperately craves by perpetuating it, but the light from logic is getting further and further away with your every successive post.” <<>> -whatever2

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $95
Hot Show
Tickets From $80
Hot Show
Buy Tickets