Well after much debating I ended up getting tickets to Henry V as well. So now I will be seeing 3 of the plays (only missing Henry IV Part 2 which is not playing during a time I can go)
Of course I feel kind of bad because BAM doesn't let you exchange shows only times/dates/seats so I still had to keep 2 tickets to shows I can't go to and buy an extra ticket for Henry V.
However I did find out they accidentally gave me a member discount on top of a sub discount despite not being a member. Well after buying 2 shows I can't go to I don't feel too bad.
Also I've been calling the box office to get seats and the guys today told me the Gallery Seats are up 70 flights of stairs with no Elevator. Something to consider for people who have trouble walking. I will be seeing 2 of the 3 shows up there (got better seats for Richard II).