I think Beautiful, Gentleman's Guide and Book Mormon have Saturday night July 4th shows. I have seen the three you mentioned plus these others, I would rank them:
1.Gentleman's Guide ... excellent!
2.Beautiful ... very good!
3.Book Of Mormon ... moderately funny the first time you see it, but not so much if you have already have.
4.It Shoulda Been You ... very light-hearted and fun book, below average score, a cross between the tv show Three's Company and the movie Bridesmaids ... but maybe not as good as either. I laughed at some, not all, of the jokes. But I don't regret seeing it. If you have seen all three listed above and you are not a crazed, obsessed dance lover (if so pick On The Town), I would choose this one out of the three you mentioned.
5.The Visit ... a real love it or hate it show, as many on the board have described it as ... I am still not sure which camp I belong to.
6.On the Town ... a real disappointment for me. The music and dancing are lovely, but the book is so so so bad, it really ruined it for me. I have nothing against dance, I really enjoyed An American In Paris ... it was what I had hoped On The Town would be. On The Town is the only show currently on Broadway I would not be willing to sit through again even if the tickets were free and they paid me the cost of a premium ticket for my time.
Updated On: 4/16/15 at 11:45 PM