AIA and HP: Same Day or Consecutive Nights

We are planning a week long trip in May and plan to see Harry Potter and Angels in America. Curious as to opinions on whether they are better seen in one day or on consecutive nights. Thinking AIA might be better over two nights given the length and subject matter while Harry Potter might be more enjoyable in one day. Also, does the TKTS booth sell AIA tickets for consecutive nights or only one part at a time? Thanks!

Updated On: 3/12/18 at 03:05 PM

I thinking doing AIA in one day would be a lot. As great as it is, it's exhausting. I'm sure the actors are exhausted as well. Add in the fact that the seats really aren't that comfortable and you'd be sitting in them for 7+ hours all in one day. I just saw it over two nights and can't imagine spending a whole day in that theatre. My knees were starting to hurt from the seats during the second part.

I just did the AIA marathon on Saturday. Part 1 goes by very quickly and comfort wasn't a major issue (at least no more than most other theatre experiences can be with the generally standard poor leg room), but by the end of Part 2, which gets a little weird, it got to be a bit of a struggle. It doesn't seem like much but that extra 20-30 minutes makes a difference - the first two acts are longer too, which doesn't help that feeling. Act III was maybe about 50 minutes or so?

All that said, it was a very neat experience to do all of that in one day. I think it also helps you notice the different growth arcs that nearly all of the characters embark on. Also, even one part is a big commitment so why not go all out? As long as you understand what you're in for, I think you'll find that ultimately it was worth it. Sleep in a bit that morning, stretch your legs during intermission, and stay away from alcohol until after the show.

Thanks for the advice. We come to NYC often so sightseeing isn't an issue, but I think I will stick with AIA over two nights.