Gonna add my two cents in here - absolutely love this show and have been fortunate enough to see some really phenomenal people play Glinda as I have been seeing it with decent regularity since 2005. From a completely objective standpoint, is Amanda the greatest singer to play Glinda? No. But, at least to me, she has a strong integrity as an actress. Her faces, her very real tears, and watching her mature throughout the show was actually kind of beautiful to watch. Her Glinda to me has a beating heart, worn on her sleeve. Obviously taste is completely subjective so to those who don't care for her performance - that's your view! But I do feel the need to defend her because I think she's fabulous!
Katie Rose Clarke is brilliant and it's wonderful to have her back!