Skip to main content
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!
Home For You Chat My Shows Register/Login Games Grosses

American Idiot or Promises, Promises

New Post Search Report Abuse Rules

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

American Idiot or Promises, Promises

Posted: 5/11/10 at 3:05pm

Edit: I have decided on Lend Me a Tenor, Everyday Rapture, and La Cage Aux Folles as three of my shows, but I still need help deciding between American Idiot and Promises, Promises.
Also, if anyone knows about the website that explains the best seating for each of the theatres, please let me know. I was linked to it from this site before, but I forgot what is was.
Thanks!
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim

Updated On: 5/13/10 at 03:05 PM

#3

Yet Another What Should I See Thread- Thanks!

Posted: 5/11/10 at 6:00pm

you will not get any sort of consensus.

Tell us a few of your favorite shows, and some of your least favorite shows and we might be able to suggest more realistically.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#5

Yet Another What Should I See Thread- Thanks!

Posted: 5/11/10 at 11:55pm

Tenor
La Cage
Fela! (Although NOT everyone's taste. I loved it OFF B'way.)

That's all I can reccommend. I've seen AI, ALNM & Rapture as well -- but cannot whole hearted reccommend them -- although others will quite disagree with me.

Last thought: the current revival of South Pacific is stunning if you haven't seen it and it has posted it's closing!
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#6

Yet Another What Should I See Thread- Thanks!

Posted: 5/11/10 at 11:58pm

LEND ME A TENOR
LA CAGE AUX FOLLES
AMERICAN IDIOT
EVERYDAY RAPTURE

In order of preference. :)
"When the audience comes in, it changes the temperature of what you've written." -Stephen Sondheim
#13

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/13/10 at 5:43pm

"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim

Updated On: 5/13/10 at 05:43 PM

#15

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/13/10 at 9:12pm

No...I don't think most would tell you AI over PP. I think you will get an even split.

I have no opinion as I have no desire to see PP. As far as AI -- it's good-ish, not great.
If we're not having fun, then why are we doing it? These are DISCUSSION boards, not mutual admiration boards. Discussion only occurs when we are willing to hear what others are thinking, regardless of whether it is alignment to our own thoughts.
#16

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/13/10 at 9:18pm

I love the music for American Idiot, and I tend to like what Mayer does with shows. I love Spring Awakening, RENT, and other rock-opera-ish, powerful shows. But I also like fun shows, if they're also good. I feel like I'd be willing to sacrifice the fact that this particular production isn't the greatest ever since I love the score and it looks very funny. It's a tough choice!
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#17

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/13/10 at 11:53pm

See Promises, Promises. It's a fantastic, big Broadway musical that never takes itself too seriously. Idiot felt like a very expensive, very pretentious senior performance art thesis project.

The audiences for both show are on polar opposite sides of the musical theatre chart.

I happen to like classic Broadway (though I think Promises often falls into post-Golden Age/Sondheim era territory) and rock musicals. I love RENT and Spring Awakening. I don't think Idiot comes even close to being a milestone (or even small dent) in Rock Opera history.

Sean Hayes is giving the best male performance in a musical on Broadway this season, in my opinion.

If you like rock musicals, see Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson at the public.
"Broadway...I'll lick you yet!"
#18

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/14/10 at 12:10am

Mildred, you make a very good case for Promises. I'm interested to hear the opinion of everyone else on here. I just feel like at this point I'd enjoy Promises more than Idiot. Plus, I've seen two shows at the St. James already (Producers/Gypsy) and I've never been in the Broadway before.

And I would see Bloody Bloody but I'm going July 6-8, so I'll just miss it.
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#19

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/14/10 at 12:56am

Sean Hayes is giving the best male performance in a musical on Broadway this season, in my opinion.


+1, saw it yesterday and one word, Wonderful, yes he is!

American Idiot is good music and a good time, but IMO a bit shallow. Promises Promises, a bit quirky/corny at times but the performances alone make up for it.
#20

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/14/10 at 2:51pm

Bump...any other opinions? I'm sort of leaning towards Promises now, but would anyone suggest Idiot over Tenor, perhaps?
"Art, in itself, is an attempt to bring order out of chaos."-Stephen Sondheim
#21

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/15/10 at 10:02am

I'm going to NY next wknd and seeing Promises, Everyday Rapture, and Andrew Jackson. Think I should try a lotto for matinee of Hair, since tour not stopping in Chicago? thanks
#22

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/15/10 at 12:32pm

See PROMISES and TENOR (anything over IDIOT)!
"Movies will make you famous; television will make you rich; but theatre will make you good." - Terrence Mann.

Updated On: 5/15/10 at 12:32 PM

#23

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/15/10 at 12:37pm

While Hayes is fantastic in "Promises," I felt that when he wasn't on stage, the entire thing lagged and kind-of bored me. "Idiot" was fast-paced and while it isn't the most amazing piece of work on Broadway right now (fast from it), it was entertaining and to me, moreso than "Promises."

#24

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/15/10 at 12:37pm

chiuptown, I've heard mixed things about the current cast, but the direction is quite brilliant and probably the best you're gonna see in a production of HAIR. If this is your only chance to see it, go!
"Broadway...I'll lick you yet!"
#25

Promises, Promises or American Idiot?

Posted: 5/15/10 at 1:19pm

I went into AI really expecting and wanting to like it.......,but. jeez, it was too loud and it seemed like a concert, with barely a plot or a time to like the characters. Great performances, but maybe I was just not into the whole suburban, straight boy, burnt out slacker whining about life.
I liked PP, though. It was fun, good music, set in a era long gone, but worth it

← Back to Message Board

BroadwayWorld TV

View all Videos

Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $59
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $95
More Hot Shows Discounts
Recommended For You