Another "what show should I see?" thread

I'll be in NYC on April 7 and I need help deciding which show to see. I've narrowed it down to these:

South Pacific - I saw it last year and loved it, but some of the cast members I fell in love with won't be there anymore and I don't know if it will be worth it.

Nine to Five - I've been a fan of Stephanie J. Block for years and would love to see her live. April 7 is the 1st NYC preview for the show, but I'm not familiar with the show or the movie.

West Side Story - One of my favorite musicals, but I've heard that the production isn't so good.

Blithe Spirit - Normally I wouldn't consider a play, but I'd love to see Christine Ebersole.

Wicked - I always enjoy it, but I've already seen it multiple times and would prefer something newer.

The Phantom of the Opera - This is the show that turned me on to professional musical theatre. I'm not really into the show anymore, but I could see it for old time's sake.

If I didn't live in the city and don't visit often, I wouldn't watch shows I've already seen, but of course that is your prerogative.

I forgot to mention Hair as a possibility. I like it, but I don't love it.

I say 9 to 5. It's completely new and fresh and I GUARANTEE you will have a good time and walk out singing the score!

And if you like Stephanie, she is really, really wonderful in the show, and has a great part.

---

Updated On: 1/8/09 at 02:20 AM

Thanks for your help. It's almost definitely going to be 9 to 5. I just need to check with the person I'm going with.