"Are you saying that LuPone's Tony is overdue??"
Rocks, I think, and please correct me if I am wrong, you have confused "overdue" and "overratted." A Tony that is overdue, is one that a performer deserved for a long time without actually winning it.
MB is saying that LaChance's Tony chances are not improved by her being "overdue" meaning, she has not been around forever and been loved, yet never won.
I am so excited for the female performances, I love Lovett, yet these other roles are also very strong, I can not wait.
I stand corrected, you are as vapid as they say.