Guh.
(spoiler warning)
I think that Sarah suddenly dying at the end of act 1 by running towards a president and getting battered to death seems ridiculously sudden and melodramatic.
It reminds me of the Baker's Wife's death in Into the Woods, random/melodramatic. (You know I definitely have misread this too if this death wasn't intentionally meant to be like this lol). Have you seen Harold+Kumar? It kind of reminds me of when the police officers randomly shouted "HE'S RESISTING" then beat the black guy when he was just standing there. (Analogy: "SHE'S GOT A GUN - beat).
Similarly, in Act II the thought of Coalhouse then taking it out on the 'town' seems ridiculous...I guess it is meant to be 'historical' though (did this actually happen in reality :/?)
Now, as I said, I'm only judging this from the cast recording+synopsis, so I'm wondering:
1. If anyone else thinks this (apparently not)
2. Perhaps it didn't transfer on the cast recording well, for me anyway. (Perhaps the timing since it's just song after song in the recording makes the death seem much more sudden and ridiculous than it is on a stage).
I find it strange that this seems surprising....I must have missed something :-/. I mean, it embarrasses me that this post may seem completely misinformed/misread/unusual/surprising etc..
I'll conclude it's just something you 'have to see'. I'm guessing you all would say "I found the story completely believable, shocking/moving".
Give me claws and a hunch, just away from this bunch.
Updated On: 10/26/09 at 05:26 PM