Overall, it was very nice to see and my friend who had never seen Rent, just loved it. Matt Caplan was a slightly better Mark than the last time I saw him, meaning he wasn't entirely offensive, but he's never made the character sympathetic for me. I didn't really care much about Mark the way I did when performed by Rapp or Butz. I do agree that there were simply too many close-ups and shaky-cam shots. It got to the point where it was nearly impossible to tell where people were on the stage and what was going on. It badly needs a re-edit.
At what point did Over the Moon become a hammy vaudeville act? In 1996 and 1997 it certainly wasn't. And I don't remember that in the first national tour. But somewhere along the line on Broadway, it stopped being about Maureen's performance art and morphed into the actress-playing-Maureen's SNL comedy sketch. It's a pity because it was one of my favorite scenes, but now, I can't wait for it to be over. It was better last night than when I saw the show in 2006, but it's still a ridiculous mess.
As far as the experience of seeing it in a movie theatre, it was fun. I wish the volume had been cranked up, however. Everything was basically at the same general conversational level and it lost some of the intensity. But the audience had a good time. They clapped for individual songs just as if they were at the live performance. They clapped along with Seasons of Love, etc. And everyone even sang along in the Seasons of Love reprise after the curtain call.
All in all, it wasn't the best cast I've seen, but far from the worst. It was a good time, but I think I'd rather see the tour, which I believe I will.
"What can you expect from a bunch of seitan worshippers?" - Reginald Tresilian