And after typing that out *whew* my thoughts... SOME SPOILERS
It seemed very pulled together for a first preview - I can't even imagine how great its going to be after a week or two. The cast was across the board solid though I will agree with those who think Asa looked a bit uncomfortable... but I think its probably something that will be remedied with more performances.
Alice Ripley and Brian D'Arcy James were both stunning - both of them know when to hold STILL on a stage - and there were several moments where they did just that instead of overemoting and I found it very emotionally effective. And they both sound incredible. I love their voices. And Alice has remarkable comic timing which really keeps the show from veering into the overly emo side of things.
There were some really effective moments emotionally - "I Miss the Mountains", "Light in the Dark", and Brian's "I Am the One" reprise... very very nice.
I agree that the first act could use a little trimming - and I think what should go is some of the songs between Henry and Natalie - they could be shortened, they seemed to go on a bit longer than necessary - but not either of Natalie's individual songs, which I thought were used very effectively, I liked what they did with "Growing Up Unstable" especially.
It was really good. I can't even imagine what its going to be like in a week or two. And my JAW was hanging open during the "Feeling Electric" number - FANTASTIC.
AGAIN SPOILERS but..
I'm unsure of what I think about how the ending was handled. Song is right, intention is right, not sure I was ok with the very final staging.. it seemed ambiguous, I turned to my friend when it was over and we were trying to decide if that was supposed to be them all "metaphorically" together or what...ok that doesn't make any sense but whatever.
Now what would you say if today I started over?
Without a thing but this taped together four leaf clover
And I'll pretend like everything is already alright
And I'll run toward the sun till the castle's out of sight
Updated On: 1/17/08 at 01:11 PM