VintageSnarker said: "$135 would be the most I've ever spent on a single ticket and if I think about it that way, I feel like I'm more likely to be disappointed in the show, but if I can work out the math with the rewards points then it might not be so bad."
I think your math is backwards. When you are paying less than that is when you are getting away with the math that doesn't support that show staying in business, the actors all making a living wage, and on and on. I love discounts, and I pay as little as I can to see a show, but... when that isn't an option, I just think of all the discounted seats I've been able to enjoy and figure every so often, it's completely fine to pay full price. I've even gone as far as paying premium for Larry David and JCM in Hedwig during their runs... if you average them out, I am still coming out way ahead. And if this is your first time paying $135, your math should work out the same.