I was! And you didn't say hello?!?
Now, my mini-review:
I enjoyed the show a lot. Now, keep in mind I got free tickets and had no, not low, but no expectations for the show. I knew very little about it and had not heard the cast recording. I will be buying it after seeing the show.
Diana is very good. Although her acting is weak, her voice, presence and spunk carry her through the show. Cleavant Derricks and Melba Moore are wonderful. I do not, however, think the show "belongs" to any one of them individually. All five performers give it their all, and, together, they create the fairy tale.
As an audience member, I think you have to agree to accept the conceit that you are being told a fairy tale by street performers and then just go with it. Once that is done, however, I think the creators short change the audience. I followed and bought into the story until the winner of the competition is announced.
SPOILER AHEAD ...
YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED ...
The real-life audience goes nuts for Brooklyn and Street Singer, as though we are the "America" that will be voting. So, how does she not win? No explanation is offered. This is not American Idol where odd things happen, and the producers cannot explain why. It is a fairy tale, and I think the audience deserves, at least, a sentence or two in the script saying, "America, though taken by Brooklyn's voice, felt cheated when her father didn't appear and voted for Paradice instead," or something like that. It's the explanation people want when the favorite is inexplicably voted off of the reality show, and the public is stunned because they can't figure out why. (I don't watch American Idol, so I can't give an example.) I know we are supposed to feel that Brooklyn gets her "happy ending" with her father, but why not let her win, give the money to the poor AND get her father?!?
More importantly, the song is never finished. I think that cheats the audience. You spend an hour and a half waiting for the rest of the song, and you don't get it. Taylor's "I can't finish something that in my heart will always be unfinished" didn't quite work for me.
In spite of that, I did really enjoy the show and will buy the cast recording.
EDIT: I found the staging very clever and highly effective, though I think the show is far too intimate to fully work in a theater the size of the Music Hall. It would benefit greatly from being seen in someplace like the Majestic.
"I am open, and I am willing,
For to be hopeless would seem so strange.
It dishonors those who go before us,
So lift me up to the light of change."
Holly Near
Updated On: 7/26/06 at 11:57 PM