Some of the people contributing to this thread have no idea what they are talking about. Especially when it comes to Bernadette's vocal proficiency and abilities.
Granted, When I saw the show in preview in March, I was REALLY scared for her, and somewhat dissapointed in her performance, but I knew that she had been sick, and a lot of other things going on with the production was affecting her performance.
I decided to go back and re-visit the show in July, and it was FANTASTIC! Bernadette was in TOP vocal form, and she really acted the hell out of that role. I would consider her the DEFINITIVE Rose. Although I am too young to have seen Merman, and Lansbury, (I still don't like Merman's interpretation from what I hear on the OBC recording, and to Lansbury was just fine) I know that Tyne Daly acted the hell out of the role, but her singing does not compare to that of Bernadette, and to me, Mama Rose needs the complete package of (Singing, Acting, Stage Presence, and Star Quality) And Bernadette's got them all.
As for comments reguarding Bernadette sounding like she's "gasping for air" on the recording, and that "she's damaging her voice" I find that to be complete foolishness. If anything, if you hear her breathing at certain intervals, that is a good thing. I have listened to the recording numerous times, and have never heard such a thing. But breathing is an integral part of singing, and there is nothing wrong with taking a nice big breath before phrases and in-between them. Breathing is your friend. As for her damaging her voice, wouldn't she be in serious trouble at this point if she had been doing anything incorrect vocally? Mama Rose is a very difficult role to sing 8 times a week. It can wear down the voice. Bernadette is fine, and doing an excellent job. Believe me, if she wasn't doing such a good job, in my humble opinion, I would agree with you, but I just find all of these negative comments to be silly and pointless.
Cheers,
The Balladeer
"Someone tell the story...Someone sing the song...."