I really think Mel has had his time on Broadway, but I wouldn't be at all surprised to see YF take home a few Tony Awards this season. I don't think that Tony voters are as disamored with Mel and his team as people on this board are. His show isn't as bad as some others, but we continually hear the same bashing from the same people. I went to see it again last week and it was obvious the performers are getting weary, but it reconfirmed my opinion that the show is better than it gets credit for on here.
The only review of a show that matters is your own.