YES! YES! YES! I've been dying to see Norm Lewis live ever since I heard him sing Javert in a recording of Les Mis. I love the idea of a deeper-voiced Phantom. As far as Sierra, I saw her a few days after her premiere in the Las Vegas version of POTO, unfortunately, from the VERY back of the theater. I saw her again in the Phantom 25th at the Majestic, again from the back of the theater. Here's my chance to see her from a good seat.
In terms of Norm Lewis's being the first Phantom of color in New York, I'm on record in my other Broadway World discussion board identity (PTOPhan) as saying that the race of the actor playing the Phantom is irrelevant, but that the Phantom himself has to be a white man to avoid changing the story. If the Phantom is anything but white, another potential reason for his mistreatment besides his disfigurement rears its head. That would certainly make a wonderful story -- a black musical genius is scorned because of his color -- but it's not the story we all troop to the Majestic to see.
Welcome to the role, Mr. Lewis. I know we'll be swooning when we hear you sing "Music of the Night."
Audrey, the Phantom Phanatic, who nonetheless would rather be Jean Valjean, who knew how to make lemonade out of lemons.