I still do think that critics have an impact on ticket sales. But some shows are critic proof, in both respects. Something like TARZAN is still running, while JOURNEY'S END is slowly dying.
Shows like TARZAN have a built-in audience. And the reason I don't think you can use shows like JOURNEY'S END, GREY GARDENS, and COMPANY to gage critics' influence is because they are shows that already have very limited audiences.
We all kind of knew from the beginning that GREY GARDENS would be a tough sell. It's such a specific, specific show that really requires prior knowledge to fully appreciate its genius.
COMPANY...it's a great production, but there are no stars, most of the acting is sub-par, the marketing is horrendous, and COMPANY was just done on Broadway about 10 years ago (even if it did suck.)
I guess people just aren't interested in them....once the real theatre buffs and culture whores are out of the way, it's on the tourist's shoulders. Sad.
"If you are going to do something, do it well. And leave something witchy."
-Charlie Manson