Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Broadway vs American Idol — Page 2

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#26

re: Broadway vs American Idol

<>>

But how did they get their name? By beating out thousands upon thousands of other people with their talent, looks, charm, personality, etc and then connecting with millions of television viewers (remember, AI could have been a total flop if the performers hadn't connected with America).

<>

Hmm.... But there are lots of suspect singers on Broadway. And lots of people who can't act. Just because you can play a certain role or do a certain track on Broadway doesn't make you an accomplished actor.

Why don't the AI people have "the package"? They have to be able to learn new songs every week and put them up onstage in front of millions of viewers. Lots of Broadway performers couldn't do that very well. Some have, in fact, tried and failed to get very far on AI.

<>

Now, you're getting somewhere. "We don't know" is quite valid. But why do you assume the worse of people when you "don't know"? Who is to say that Fantasia isn't a TERRIFIC actress? I think her work on AI reflects that of someone who would make a terrific actress.

<>

Very interesting. First of all, everyone takes a different route to Broadway. It's not "hard" for everyone. Heck, some people move to this town and book the first Broadway show they audition for. Some are discovered in other venues and begged to do Broadway shows when they don't even want to. Why do you think that someone doesn't deserve Broadway unless they struggle for many years first? Why must it be hard?

<>

Why so much bitterness towards television? TV is a forum in which to be seen by millions of people. If you can get on TV and then connect with those people, well.... hey, that's showbusiness for ya.
#27

re: Broadway vs American Idol

Its hard to defend your views when two other people are charging at you from other directions.
But I am not one to give up!
I understand that TV and Broadway are two
total different "industries" and yes, sometimes
people go see a show for a curtain someone, and thats totally fine. Making my statement short and simple. My opinion is that its not fare that people who devote their entire life to becoming a Broadway actor have to watch out for Pop "idols".
Its something that us stage actors have to deal with!
#29

re: Broadway vs American Idol

"I'll buy that" is referring to the comment about Simon being ignorant about Broadway.

As for BroadwayLead's most recent comments... dude... it's not about fair and unfair. Why be victimized by this? It's PART OF THE GAME. Play it. Broadway tickets are 100 dollars each. If people are to pay that money, they want to make SURE the show is good. As a performer, it is YOUR job to be that person who is good. The only way they can KNOW that you are good is... if you get a good review in the newspaper or even better, if you promote yourself to the millions potential ticket buyers by appearing in front of them on television.

Why not learn from what you're seeing? If people want a NAME... if you're going to dedicate your "entire" life to a career on Broadway... you better recognize that some of your life needs to be dedicated towards getting that name recognition which will give you a better chance of booking good roles on Broadway. Why hate the game when you can play it?

That is showbusiness. Show. And then do business.

Updated On: 10/23/04 at 10:09 PM

#30

re: Broadway vs American Idol

I have to say that after hearing Clay Aiken on the new Aladdin DVD... I think he has definite potential for Broadway. Don't know if he can act, though.
#31

re: Broadway vs American Idol

I hate to be nitpicky about this, but KIMBERLY Caldwell was #7 out of the top 12 of the second season.
#32

re: Broadway vs American Idol

Let's not forget Scooter Girl (in talks for Rent, supposedly), or the cute boy (Marcus? Marquise?) who was in Fame! off-broadway. Neither even made the top 12!
#33

re: Broadway vs American Idol

And if you want to see a wasted talent, check out the guy who won the International Idol contest. Dont hear much from him, and yet he had a voice that would seriously melt butter.
"That duck was a sexual toy, and it was on display!" -- an unknown Nashville town leader
#34

re: Broadway vs American Idol

Yes SPEED, I totally get what you are saying!
This is a business and I that want to be in this business
should know about the game, and I think im playing alright!
Yes its true what you are saying about recognition.
I am one, who dont mind my neighbors. If pop-stars want to be Broadway stars, so be it. What I really care about is
how I am playing, and how to win.
(Funny how a small topic can cause such debate)lol

American Idol coming Janurary 2005
Broadway, Watch out!
#35

re: Broadway vs American Idol

Simon dosn't know his ass from his elbow about Broadway.

Calling a male contestant 'too Broadway' was his way of saying 'too gay'.

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71