I've seen CHICAGO well over 100 times and now I don't live in NYC anymore. I've been depressed about not getting to see new shows (WICKED, SPAMALOT, SPELLING BEE, etc.) but now I am WAY depressed to not get to see this show right now! (I got to play Mary Sunshine here locally a couple of years ago, though).
I would LOVE it if they did a new recording with Brooke. She sounded amazing on the video clip. I'm not sure if I like the wig, though. They could get great people from throughout the history of the run to play all the parts. Sharon Lawrence as Velma, Mary Testa as Mama, Ernie Sabella as Amos, Michael Berresse as Billy Flynn. (Just a few suggestions).
You can never have too many recordings of a brilliant score like this. I have every English language cast recording (and the soundtrack) and ripped tracks from all of them to make MY ultimate CHICAGO recording. I even have me as Mary Sunshine (insert Narcissist joke here) and Liza Minnelli doing the Roxie monologue. Bebe, Chita, Catherine Zeta Jones, Ute Lemper as Velma/ Gwen, Ann, Liza, Ruthie, Renee as Roxi/, Jerry, James, Michael, Richard as Billy/ Joel, Barney as Amos/ Marsha, Queen Latifah as Mama... you get the idea. I would love to be able to add a new recording in and decide which new tracks to use.
Okay, now that you know I have NO life.... who would you choose to make up an ultimate CHICAGO recording. NOT someone who has recorded it before, someone who has played the role on Broadway and you would love to hear on CD?!?!!??!?
<-- Tevye, FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, March 2018