Skip to main content
Shop Merch Add a Show Listing
My Shows
News on your favorite shows, specials & more!

Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Welcome Guest. Please Login or Register.

#1

Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

I LOVED the singing. These 5 actors have such tremendous voices. Kevin (Taylor) and Cleavant (Streetsinger) have such a beautiful tone to their voices. Ramona (Paradice) whoa - very different, unbroadway like, strong and clear, Karen (Faith) beautiful, rich sound and Eden...damnnnn.. that girl can SANGGGGGGGGGGG. So soft one minute and the next strong and powerful.

I LOVED the acting. ALL 5 actors made me believe their characters. I was moved to tears mainly by Cleavant and Taylor.

I LOVED the set and costumes. I could have never imagined that almost everything they wore was made of things OTHER than clothes. I never knew a garbage bag could look so GOOD on someone.. and the homeless look was so unbelievablely real I swore I was looking into an alley on the street. The broken down building on stage was such a clever idea that I never knew how they would go 90 minutes without changing the scene but how they did it was MARVELOUS.

Favorite song - Eden singing Once upon a time followed by her duet with Cleavant towards the end.

Favorite character - Tie between Faith - so hip and beautiful she makes you notice her and Paradice - Every scene she was in commanded your attention.

Favorite performer - Cleavant - He told the story so clear, his acting moved me to tears and his voice was such a joy to hear.

Now for the bad....

I HATED the fact that there was no intermission. Those seats are not comfortable enough for 90 minutes straight.

I HATED the fact that Eden did not have another signature song besides Once Upon a time..Her voice is so beautiful to hear she should have song MORE. Actually Paradice to me seemed like the lead in that show.

I HATED that Eden's best number was in the first 5 mintues when it could have been a show stopping "Defying gravity" type ending and THEN they could have an intermission.

I HATED that the 5 actors didnot sing more as a unit because the first song Heart behind these hands is AWESOME. I wanted more of those type songs.

I HATED that Taylor - who is HOT HOT HOT...and Faith did not have another solo musical number because they sure have star quality and fantastic voices.

All in all - I would pay to see it again. I laughed, I cried and it was such a fun night. But to those who know people out there - please....

WE NEED AN INTERMISSION,... GIVE EDEN 2 more SONGS.. she doesn't have enough of them and GIVE FAITH a hip hop street number to rock the house. She can definitely dance and is a joy to watch.

Any questions?
#4

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

It's not nonsense! Having it be one act makes a lot of sense when it's that short. What about ASSASSINS, MAN OF LAMANCHA . . . are those seats more comfortable???
#5

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Man of La Mancha was just awful the whole way through.... nothing was comfortable about it, so there isn't only a pain in your ass from sitting, but also your eyes and ears. I thought Brooklyn would be a typical Bway show, i didn't expect a 90 min. straight run. But it's different, and i'll see how a feel about it when i see it. The only review i heard was that the seats are uncomfortable, so i'm basing my "nonsense" on that re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

#6

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Well the show started a little late,, about 8:15 and I walked out it was about 10:00 so that too damn long for me. Especially since the seats are small on the sides and in front. I had a cramp in my legs from not stretching.

However - Give all those actors another song to sing..they are outstanding actors and singers!!! and hellooooo...why does Paradice have several knock out songs when Eden has only one? The title might have to be changed to Paradice & Bklyn!
#10

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Just to nitpick, is 90 minutes really THAT long to sit without an intermission? I mean, if you go to a show that runs about two and a half hours, the first act tends to be around 75 minutes long. Does the extra 15 minutes make that much of a difference?

#11

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Newcomer - Chill out..Its the new Wicked cause it had its first preview yesterday and people will talk about it..

My favorite songs -

1. Once upon a Time -Eden
2. Raven - Paradice
3. Superlover - Paradice
3. Heart behinds these hands -Ensemble
4. Streetsinger - Eden & Cleavant

and all the rest are actually just nice sounding songs.. not show stopping to me like the ones above so you see...

Producers -- GIVE EDEN MORE SONGS... If she didn't sing OUAT...I think Paradice would have stole that show!
#13

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Newcomer - Chill out..Its the new Wicked cause it had its first preview yesterday and people will talk about it..

I am "chilled" I just don't know why it can be in one post like some of the other shows :) I for one would like to see the show and may do so this evening. Nothing against the show. Don't hate re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated
#14

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Tiny - Paradice is AMAZING and to be honest...Eden was vocally outstanding but her acting was just nice... and average...

Like for instance.. I saw her in Wicked..when she did DG..her voice gave me chills but there was no expression on her face as she flew in the air...she SANG mostly whereas when I saw Idina in the same part..her facial expressions and hand gestures WENT with the song...so Idina can ACT what she sings. Eden can SING and act but not together if you know what I mean...
#15

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Newcomer - sorry... I didn't know all posts about a show go in one thread...Its been tried before but what's the big deal if there's more than one anyway?
#19

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

haha... it doesn't matter what anyone says... there will be like 1000 threads for every topic. Even random ass Wicked reviews are still being posted.

WickedFan- def. let me know what to look out for on Oct. 9th... from what i heard i should pay attention to other characters besides Eden, which is cool...
#20

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

What's the big deal about sitting for 90 minutes without an intermission? I'm sure that you sit longer than that for almost every movie that you see. I guess that you guys will never go and see "The Iceman Cometh", "Angels In America" or "Nicholas Nickleby". Sometimes it's just better not to break the flow of the show..
"Smart! And into all those exotic mystiques -- The Kama Sutra and Chinese techniques. I hear she knows more than seventy-five. Call me tomorrow if you're still alive!"
#21

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Funny how A Chorus Line ran for 15 years without an intermission and I don't remember a whole lot of people complaining about it (and IT was two hours).
"What a story........ everything but the bloodhounds snappin' at her rear end." -- Birdie [http://margochanning.broadwayworld.com/] "The Devil Be Hittin' Me" -- Whitney
#22

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Well technically, alot of Bway 1st acts are about 90 mins. long... i just can't imagine, from hearing the synopsis of the show, that BKLYN is that short. Does it seem cut off? Or is the story well developed enough in short amount of time? Just curious...
#23

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Hey, if 90 minutes is long enough for "Dude, Where's My Car", it's good enough for Brooklyn, too.
"Fundamentalism means never having to say 'I'm wrong.'" -- unknown
#24

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

Pab and Margo - Maybe those shows had bigger seats! The space to the side and to the front was tinyyyyyyy. My arm kept hitting the guy next to me's arm and if my husband went his legs would be up to his neck when he sat cause he's 6'4!

and its not 90 minutes total...cause you get there about 7:30 lets say.. the show started after 8:00 and it ended about 10:00 so that was more than 2 hours..like 2 1/2 total. And yes in a movie its usually more than 2 hours but their seats have lots of space in front to stretch your legs and the seats are wide!
#25

re: Brooklyn 9/23 - What I loved - What I Hated

While I agree that two hours is usually not too long to sit without an intermission, some theatres make it hard because those seats are extremely uncomfortable and after too long your ass does start to hurt.


"Noah, someday we'll talk again. But there's things we'll never say. That sorrow deep inside you. It inside me, too. And it never go away. You be okay. You'll learn how to lose things..."

BroadwayWorld TV


Ticket Central
Hot Show
Tickets From $58
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71
Hot Show
Tickets From $71