I'm sorry I dug this out from way back, but I missed it somehow the first go around. Here is my thoughts on Cabaret my favorite musical in the world.
When it comes to some things about theatre's current state of being, such as casting, people are often left puzzled.
I think Cabaret's best asset, and a fact that most people did not realize, was that the actors in the show made up the orchestra. They all played one instrument, and many of them played even more. There were a few dedicated cast members who actually stayed in the company throughout the show's entire run including the wonderful Michael O'Donnell-who played a character named Bobby(he also happen to be one of the best Emcee's I ever saw, and if I remember correctly, he only got to play the part twice-a Sunday matinee and evening performance.) He's in Wonderful Town now, so go see it...
Another cast member who was involved with the revival since the beginning was Vance Avery(who also happens to be one of the best Emcee's I ever saw). He is actually still involved with the shows current Asian tour. From day one he was Alan Cumming's understudy, and it's quite striking how much they actually resemble each other. I never understood why he never got to be the Emcee for a certain amount of time other than inbetween B-list celebs. There were a few other original cast members who closed the show but I'm having trouble recalling any others without glancing at my Playbill. During the show's run, castmembers included Alan Cumming, Michael C Hall, Matt McGrath, Natasha Richardson, Ron Rifkin, Hal Linden, Tom Bosley, Jon Secada, John Stamos, Adam Pascal, Raul Esparza(twice), Brooke Shields,Molly Ringwald, Jane Leeves, Susan Egan, Melina Kanakeredes, Joeley Fisher, Debbie Gibson, Neil Patrick Harris, Norbert Leo Butz (he was only involved in the tour) and a whole bunch more that I can't remember of the top of my head.
I think their biggest mistake was they tried to get people to see the show for all the wrong reasons. The show was origionally supposed to make you think, "Whoa, what just happened here?" But because people were paying their 65 bucks to see a certain person they liked watching as a teen, the show lost a lot of dignity. Audience members always laughed at very serious points in the show that really are not funny at all, but just becasue they see someone like John Stamos walk out on stage wearing a beautiful dress and high heels, they feel the need to laugh.
May it rest in peace!
Sorry this is so long-I just always felt very passionate about this show.
"What a mystery this world. One day you love them and the next day you want to kill them a thousand times over." The Masked Bandit in THE FALL