Great thread!
The cabaret soundtrack(yes, soundtrack) was my first exposure ever to musical theatre--my aunt used to play it as she drove me to nursery school and I fell in love w/ it. Very funny how much more I've learned about it since then...
Couple of things...the disturbing thing...I guess the finale as well but since I would want my answer to include all versions of the show, I would definitely have to say Tomorrow Belongs To Me. The way it's so easily started, and everyone joining in and the hypnotizing way...I mean esp. more so in the movie, seeing children sucked in...just terrifying(and I too loved and well still do this song before knowing it's meaning).
The cabaret itself...like Hal Prince said in the PBS series, Cabaret took place in two worlds--the real one and "limbo"(Kit Kat Club.) Everything that was shown in the club commented on things going on in the real world. Obviously, "If You Could See Her," but others as well(keep in mind I only saw the stage show once so most of the stuff I mention esp. involving songs are prob more from the soundtrack which I know better).
Someone made a great point in showing that both Sally and the Cabaret really stood for the Germans who did nothing just lived a pleasant life, ignoring what was happening to the Jews. The connection between the two completely come together in Sally's rendition of "Cabaret." The idea that life's a cabaret, a breeze, we don't need to be "political."
I personally found a big difference at least between Joel Grey's movie Emcee and the revival Emcee. Joel Grey's emcee I really did feel was more of an instigator, embracing everything going on, quietly commenting on it, getting people to go the cabaret, the place where no troubles are, and just seemed to be enjoying everything going on. For awhile I thought the same of the revival emcee until the end, when I realized he wasn't the instigator, but the victim. Nice twist.
Fav song...Mein Herr and Cabaret, ever since I was little...I loved "belting"(not that I can now and however I sang when I was younger) those tunes out and still do.
Seeing the show...once...Jon Secada and Melina. I thought they were fine, but I've become more critical since then, and have nothing to compare it to, but I still enjoyed it. I remember wishing Melina would sing a bit better but than enjoyed her "Cabaret." I really remember liking Jon. ::shrugs::
One last thing...it's really weird, though I love the movie soundtrack, I think I like the book of the show much better than the script of the movie. I dunno, I like the story between Herr Schultz and Fraulein errr shoot can't remember names...well yeah. I liked that story better than the younger couple story told, and just...eh lots of stuff.
"If there was a Mount Rushmore for Broadway scores, "West Side Story" would be front and center. It snaps, it crackles it pops! It surges with a roar, its energy and sheer life undiminished by the years" - NYPost reviewer Elisabeth Vincentelli