aaaaaa15 said: While I appreciate what you're saying, I've seen people say they didn't realize Phillipa was Asian and she herself has said she had never been talked about as an actor of color before Hamilton. I think it's important that we don't erase the ethnicities of 'white-passing' actors. As long as Hamilton has a wide range of ethnicities then I don't think it matters too much if certain actors aren't white but look white to some people.
True. I get your point about not erasing "white-passing" actors. Phillipa has also said, though, that the most rewarding experience to her has been when young Asian people tell her that she has been an inspiration to them seeing her in such a prominent role. Which is a point that I think a lot of white people miss, the awe at seeing someone who represents your ethnicity (or near enough) doing something that white people usually get defaulted into.
I'm sure Carleigh is lovely and I've heard only positive reviews of her going on as Eliza. I'm not specifically criticizing her, and maybe I'm wrong in assuming she is Caucasian -- I just see so much dream-casting of white actors as Hamilton characters, which is tedious because it misses the point entirely.
Hamilton Emotional Support Group:
https://www.facebook.com/groups/hamiltonsupport/