The OBC has a more theatrical feel to it. Sounds more like a real show than the concept recording. Both are good though but I prefer the OBC with Judy Kuhn. Love her.
I've not heard the Danish recording, but if it's a choice between the OBC and the Concept, I'd go with the Concept album. The OBC has some great perfomances (esp. Judy Kuhn), but the London recording is absolutely thrilling (everything sounds so BIG...the orchestra, the voices) and Elaine Paige sings the hell out of Florence's songs (the part was written expressly for her).
Completely trivial sidenote: I remember reading an interview with Sarah Michelle Gellar back when Buffy the Vampire Slayer was still on the air, and the interviewer asked her for her five "Desert Island Discs"; she included the OBC recording of Chess on her list (not quite sure why I found that interesting, but I did).
I think I've decided though. I'm gonna go find the OBC recording. The London sounds so synthesized.
How are the arrangements on the OBC? I really loved how what I've heard from the benefit really brought out the rock in the score. Julia's "Nobody's Side." Thrilling.
I am always the odd one out whenever this question comes out. I detest the original concept because of Elaine Paige's performance. Screech, Shout, Screech, Shout. It's a wonder one man would want her Florence, let alone two. shudder. My votes goes for the OBC. You get a more desirable Florence and no other Anatoly can hold a candle to the divine David Carroll, may he and his beautiful voice R.I.P.
I prefer the performances on the OBC overall, though the version of One Night in Bangkok you hear on the radio all the time is from the concept album, so it tends to ring truer to me, perhaps because repetition has made it so familiar. In addition, the Arbiter song at the beginning ("from square one I'll be watching all 64...") is not on the OBC and I love it. I prefer David Caroll's Anatoly -- his "Anthem" is just about perfection. Hard choice, I know.
i have the beroadway one and its very good. the star, david carrol i believe, was best friends with my teacher, but sadly he passed away.
"You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view - until you climb into his skin and walk around in it."
To Kill A Mockingbird
I have four versions - London, Broadway, cocnert, Danish. I actually find myself listening to the Danish one most frequently, though it annoys me that the songs are in a weird order -- why is Pity the Child (one of my all time favorite songs) in the first act???
That is because Chess Danish is following the original London script closely. in original London version, Pity the Child is in the act1. This was changed later in broadway version.