FLAHOOLEY(1951) starring a very young Barbara Cook, at Philadelphia's Shubert Theatre. It lasted 40 performances at the Broadhurst in NYC.
PLAIN & FANCY(1955), also starring Barbara Cook, at Philadelphia's Forrest Theatre. It had a then profitable run of 461 performances at the Mark Hellinger in NYC.
THE GIRL WHO CAME TO SUPPER(1963), starring Florence Henderson and Jose Ferrer, at Philadelphia's Shubert Theatre. It played the Broadway in NYC for only 113 performances, despite getting 3 rave reviews and only 1 unfavorable one. I saw it many times, and "second acted" it multiple times in my heavy drinking days.
THE YEARLING(1965) at Philadelphia's Shubert Theatre, starring David Wayne and Dolores Wilson. It played the Alvin in NYC and lasted 3 performances after receiving 5 pans, which it deserved.
"Madam Rose...and her daughter...Gypsy!"