Well, I went last night and was in the third row. The seats were cheap and perfectly good. Although I was never emotionally moved (nor surprised, as I had seen the film), I thought thought the production was pretty decent. Certainly not as bad as I was led to believe by the reviews.
The characters were a bit one-note, and not really played with much colour. The set and the lighting, and certainly the direction (could we have a pause now and then? it would have been effective at certain moments--such as, in the climactic scene, Fr. Flynn asks Sr. Aloysius if she's ever committed a mortal sin... shouldn't she stop and think before answering?!) didn't help. It seems like the show should be rich, when it's actually rather bland.
I did like the humour. The final line gave me a different conclusion than in the film (different in the sense of what I think Sr. Aloysius meant). And overall I was not displeased.
I stayed for the Talkback after the performance. I decent-sized crowd stayed afterwards. They seemed to largely be seniors, some of whom went to Catholic school back in the day and for whom the play brought back memories. The Talkback session, though, wasn't well managed, and there wasn't a good opportunity for discussion and questions of the themes of the play. David Storch, Daniella Vlaskovic and a moderator attended the session. May try and go to Canstage Theatre Club on Saturday.
Coach Bob knew it all along: you've got to get obsessed and stay obsessed. You have to keep passing the open windows. (John Irving, The Hotel New Hampshire)