I absolutely loved THE LIFE and if I had to name my favorite flop that I actually saw, I'd probably go with that one. But it wasn't a great show. It jumped off the stage and the performances were great but there was a definite air of - not camp, exactly, but it both was and wasn't taking itself seriously somehow. It felt like an A cast doing a C+ show with a cracking score.
I don't think there's enough meat or substance there for it to be an actual realistic show about that time and place. I fear trying to make it live up to today's social standards and be a "responsible" look at the street culture of the early '80s is just going to remove whatever made it exciting in the first place.
And Sonya would have a grand total of a lot higher than 15,000 if Lilias were to play the role today, much as I love her. My memory is that during the applause for "Oldest Profession" she full-on chugged an entire mug of beer in one long gulp and got even more applause. And "My Body" is one of the all-time great production numbers I've seen onstage. I'll be excited to see who they cast.