I love this pic, and I've always thought that John would do a bang-up job as Edna!
My only concern... and hopefully it's a small one... is how "plastic" his face looks with all that rubber on his cheeks. Kinda like Bette Midler in that "old age" makeup at the end of For The Boys. It looks a bit like a melting wax figure.
You can't really see it much in the scan here, but it shows better (or worse?) in the magazine photo.
I hope they didn't overdo his makeup... in going for a realistically pudgy, feminine look, they may have just tried too hard in that department. I haven't seen enough pictures to know for sure, but there's something "not right" about the skin on his face.
Just my premature 2 cents. But I've had the same reaction now a couple of times to seeing him as Edna.
"Jaws is the Citizen Kane of movies."
blocked: logan2, Diamonds3, Hamilton22