For other things to do...If you are there on a Friday, Target sponsors free admission to MoMa (Museum of Modern Art) on Fridays starting at 4:00. I have seen long lines so you may want to get there a bit early. Although the line seems to move fairly fast.
The answer to this question is obvious: GYPSY.
GYPSY, without a doubt. If you are into plays, however, then August: Osage County. Since this is your first time in NY and your first Bway show, treat yourself to something that will wow you. I wouldn't recommend [title of show] as anyone's first Broadway experience ... it will be a complete letdown and disappointment.
Videos