I genuinely enjoyed it, I must say. Also, it was refreshing to hear the score. Sure, there were a ton of problems, but sometimes its good to let the criticism cap off and just let yourself get swept away.
Ellen Greene annoyed the crap out of me. Scott Bakula did well, and while I love me some Stokes, I felt like he was missing something.
But here's what shocked me. Jessica Biel didn't suck. Now, she's not gonna win any awards for sure, but she could carry a tune (carry, sometimes not overly well, but she didn't make me want to die), and while her acting wasn't strong, she managed to hold her own with Brian Stokes Mitchell. In fact, when I was watching her, I didn't see "OMG it's Justin Timberlake's Girlfriend", but I was watching an immature Sarah Brown.
Deet: Shira, I Love You!