Stub Hub and Ticketmaster tickets will be available, at roughly the same price as today, up until the week of/ day of the performance. The Richard Rogers theater is actually small (1300-ish seats), so there really isn’t a bad seat...especially in the Orchestra...even on the far sides.
I was very fortunate on a Valentines Day, a sorta holiday like Halloween. We were walking past the theater and I was telling my boyfriend how I previously got tickets in the cancellation line. The cop that watches that block herd our conversation and said...now is the time to see the show if your interested...cancellation line is short. So we stood in line with two couples ahead of us and...got 2 tickets, row F, Center Orchestra, on the aisle for $219 each.
There is so much happening in NY on Halloween...you just might get lucky too.