I think FELA! should burn in hell. I walked out during Act 1 (first time I'd ever done that). It was the most excruciatingly boring and infuriating time I'd ever spent at the theater. I'd rather flush my money down the toilet after wiping my A$$ with it than spend another penny to sit in that theater again.
Out of the dismal nominees, I'd probably say MILLION DOLLAR QUARTET because I had a better time at that show than any of the others. Now, that doesn't mean I think it deserves that award. EVERYDAY RAPTURE does.