I've only seen the pictures, but Raul Esparza makes for one hot Emcee. Very different from the "old man" I watched in the movie when I was little. Hey, when you're 8, Joel Grey at 40 seems ancient.
Once again, based on pictures, but Jai Rodriguez is probably the prettiest Angel, because many of the others have looked horrible in drag. Damien DeShaun Smith from the tour was also totally adorable. My sister didn't even realize he was a guy until she read the program at intermission, and even then it was only because he had facial hair in his headshot.
Like a firework unexploded
Wanting life but never
knowing how