I am old enough to have followed the Papp-Moses controversy carefully at the time---all the references and names dropped in the play are familiar to me. As I watched the play Sunday afternoon, I was always interested, but the further away I get from it, the more disappointed I feel.
A few points: much as I liked the actors and the ensemble feeling they created, they all seemed terribly similar---almost as if they had come from the same drama school. Very little variety in the tone of the piece--were those real life people so similar?
As I considered it, each character seemed to have one affect: Vaughan: ambition; Papp: feistiness; Debuskey: friendship and support; Gersten: about the same. Of the women, you could say that Dewhurst and Peggy Papp were fairly well drawn, but the other two women seemed to me very underwritten.
Why was the Papp-Moses conflict dropped between the second and third scenes? . Did everyone in the audience understand that Papp had won out, and that a Judge had declared that te festival had the right to perform Shakespeare in Central Park for free, over Moses' objections? I found this frustrating,
Here are some facts that might be helpful if you have not seen the play and are planning to.
T, refers to T Edward Hambleton, who ran the Pheonix Theater, an off Broadway classical theater that was at 12th street and second avenue (now a movie theater) and did a season of plays, mostly classical, It was the only not for profit of the era, and I guess, existed on money from Mr. Hambleton and ticket sales. The plays they did in that theater were of pretty high quality, before Vaughan took over in 58, Tyrone Guthrie directed a few classics there. By being appointed the resident director, it meant Vaughan could plan and direct at least four productions a year there, with a company of off Broadway actors whom he could choose.
George C Scott, the actor playing Jacques in the student attended production of As You Like It, was an amazing actor. In the fall of 57, the Festival was able to do a season at the Hecksher Theater (the first scene of Illyria takes place in the back stage area of that theater) and Scott came out of nowhere to play a galvanic Richard III, directed by Vaughan. As You Like It was the second production of that season, Also in it were Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara, playing two of the rustics. But Scott, drunk or not, was an amazing stage actor---for me his presence, so different from the easy going nature of the actors on stage at the Anspacher, was sorely missed.