Idina Musical Movie

Why would I pay money to listen to Idina sing in a movie when I can pour battery acid in my ears for free instead?

BwayLB said: "I've been a fan of Idina Menzel a little while before Frozen made her the legend she is 26 years after Rent. The first time i heard her sing (like some of you) of course was the Wicked cast album. Then i saw her as Nancy in Enchanted then bits of her I Stand CD. I discovered Glee over a year ago with her as April. I think more than ever it's time Hollywood or Netflix should give her a movie musical with her as the lead. Whether an original musical or adaptation, Idina deserves to expand her outside New York fanbase beyond Elsa. Who's with me"

You're about to discover this board is NOT full of Idina fans.

I am one, however, for more than a decade, and as talented as she is and as mainstream as she now is - more or less anyway - she, without being an animated character, likely cannot carry a big-budget movie as the lead. She does great in ensembles, i.e. Enchanted, but I genuinely don't think she's a lead movie star, even if it's a singing role.

Unless it was the Wicked movie.

JanMaxwellsBag said: "Dang, where you getting this free battery acid? It’s 10.99 a gallon at the battery acid store near me. And even if I want to DIY it, it’s still ten bucks for a pack of double A’s.

ETA: I would also like to see Idina do more film projects, musical or not. She was pretty great in Uncut Gems (a movie I liked more than I thought I would)."

Fair point, although with most movie theatres charging $18 now, that's still cheaper. Although I will agree, she was good in Uncut Gems (where thankfully she didn't sing).