Yup. I have never seen a show on Broadway, since I live in Canada and would never in a million years pay an excess of money to travel to see most things on the Great White Way.
But I have seen touring productions and Mirvish imports of Next to Normal (tragically unmoving, even with Alice Ripley), Spring Awakening (one brief moment of electricity), Wicked (the ending sent me into a fit of giggles), The Lion King, Hairspray, and Rock of Ages among others. And given the general effect each of these shows had on me, it'd take a show like Hamilton to get me to invest in crossing the border. There was no sense of liveness. Except, duh, the actors were alive and stuff.
I will, however, likely be making the trek to see Hamilton. It's the first time a bunch of video footage of a show has literally taken my breath away, which is good indication that the show itself might do the same.