You are all right.
I did do all the tourist things last May, ESB, Top of the Rock, Carriage ride in Central Park, Statue of Liberty, shopped til I dropped and saw 5 shows (should have been 6 but Xanadu preview was canceled)but I found that we were on the go the entire time.
I never really got to experience good food though because we'd be out all day and then have to rush out to dinner and then the theater. It made some of the shows lose their excitement somewhat.
I think for Avenue Q, I could probably decide on the day and still get a ticket - but I am fussy about my tickets.
Thanks everyone, you are right - I will get a ticket. After all I can give it away if I have a change of heart.
'Downtown Elaiggghhhy?'