jayinchelsea said: "I've read all the comments, and frankly left me confused. I had a good time, it was fun, great to see Sutton and Jonathan, loved the opening, loved most of what they did (not the Fred and Ginger, though), and still think Jeanine is extraordinarily talented. Like most of the new material. Thrilled that I was there. Sorry!"
You're not alone, I loved it as well. I don't mind when things like this are a little messy; that's part of the fun to me. I quite enjoyed most of the new work as well, and I thought both of Shaina Taub's contributions ("Room" and "When"
were beautiful. I was there with my mom, who also had a wonderful time.
I personally enjoyed Groff singing some more pop songs and the Patty Griffin song that Sutton sang. I get to hear these people sing musical theater all the time; it offers some nice insight to hear them sing other kinds of music they enjoy. When I saw Groff at Joe's Pub several years ago the set was almost entirely made up of pop songs and it was fantastic, including a couple of Joni Mitchell songs and a Stevie Wonder song, so I wasn't surprised to hear more of that here. Sutton in particular pleasantly surprised me with her subdued take on the Patty Griffin song and "Stars and the Moon." I quite like her but I don't think she's the most versatile vocalist, but her versions of both of those, along with "Room" at the beginning of the evening, were very beautiful and restrained. She's matured wonderfully as an actress; I adored her performance in Violet and think she's wonderful on Younger as well. I hope we get to see her back onstage soon.