Jennifer Hudson singing "And I'm Telling You" live

http://jenniferhudsonmusic.com/jennifer003.html

---

---

Updated On: 3/2/05 at 06:22 PM

I hope she can act because she'd be a very good Effie. Then again, Holliday was no great actress in the beginning, so with a good director, Hudson should be fine.

---

Yeah, just keep the original brilliant staging on the key moments, and the role is near impossible to mess up. Totally impossible (I think) if you have someone who can sang.

---

*sits down after doing a little dance around the room*

GO HEAD GIRL! That's it, write the contract so she can sign it. SHE NEEDS TO BE EFFIE!

I love how I never see Margo anymore unless it's in a Dreamgirls thread.

---

are you people serious?
she is obviously imitating Holliday like most black woman.
with "aity" people are going to cheer even if the person sounds horrible.

i dont buy it

"And im telling you"

I think with the right musical director/vocal coach/director...she could PULL IT OFF. What I like about her is that she wasnt quite imitating Holliday - she seems to be able to know how to add her own runs and style - and hopefully like I said w the right musical director they'll keep pushing her singing of the song away from the same old Holliday notes and riffs. She also is young, and looks young - which is really important for this role. I love Frenchie - but she does not have enough gospel "rawness" in her voice. She sounds too trained - I'm not saying she has a 'deena' voice, because she does has a powerful, very high belt. But Frenchie had a long time to make "and i am" her own, and at the end she was still hitting the Holliday notes that everyone sings.

ive said it before, and ill say it again: JENNIFER HUDSON IS EFFIE WHITE. bill condon has got to get in touch with her, this could make her a star.

---

Wow.

I've said this since the moment I heard about a possible revival or movie; Jennifer Hudson needs to be Effie. I saw her in the American Idol concert last summer and she blew me away and even posed for a picture in the middle of the concert (after I threw her a rose). Work it girl!!

---

NO. Not even remotely.

Remember the song was written FOR her voice, for what it sounded like, for its range and power and timbre, for what it can do. It's not as if Krieger and Eyen handed her the finished song and she just sang it. They heard her and were totally blown away by her and set out to construct a song to exploit all of the things that she could do that few other singers have ever been able to. It's not just her signature song -- the song is her and she is the song. Her performance goes beyond definitive -- those slides and growls were written into the score after their first draft of the song once they heard how she interpreted the initial version.

You'd never have made such an utterly uninformed comment had you ever witnessed her perform the song live in the show. I've seen nearly every other Effie and dozens of others over the years do the song and NO ONE is even in the same ballpark. Holliday OWNS the song now and forever and if you don't like "her version" you don't like the song as it is intended to be sung. To suggest otherwise is ludicrous.

---

Updated On: 3/3/05 at 02:39 AM