I saw it last night and, as it stands now, it's dazzling and frustrating in equal measures.
There is some impressive aerial work with a big white sheet that lifts Titania into the upper regions of TFNA's nifty new space, but many of the actors still seemed to be finding their footing and, although Taymor brings lots of neat stagecraft to the proceedings, there's a sense of just too-too. The stagecraft could use some editing, and that's including the too on-the-nose homages to THE LION KING.
Kathryn Hunter has an utterly unique speaking voice that adds some character to Puck, but the character, as it stands now, is all flourish and contortions (Full disclosure: I don't like when Puck is played by a female) and no spontaneity. In fact, a lack of spontaneity affects nearly all the players. Max Casella comes across the best as Bottom, but the performance of Pyramus and Thisbe doesn't satisfy. As Hermia, Lilly Englert seems to be on her way to giving a good performance as a spoiled princess Hermia, but the slim, pretty Mandi Masden is miscast and looks lost as Helena. Yes, there are shirts taken off and abs of the night go to Zach Appelman's Demetrius. The lovers chasing each other through a forest of white panels was the visual high point of the second act.
There's more stick usage in this show than in the entire careers of Peter Brook and Andrei Serban combined. Paper, cardboard, and white pillows are also used throughout perhaps showing Taymor making a concerted effort to keep it simple. She could keep it simpler, though. Tens of tumbling children who are the fairies are used throughout the show and always seem to be just on the verge of injury. A little disconcerting, this, and could be trimmed down. Elliot Goldenthals music is heavy-handed and sort of dreary.
That said, it's still MIDSUMMER. It's indestructible. Even half-baked the show still delivers. So...yeah. Why not? Go see it. There were plenty of empty seats last night.
Oh, and Sven Ortel's awesome projections were the high point of the first act. I loved the moths!
"Impossible is just a big word thrown around by small men who find it easier to live in the world they've been given than to explore the power they have to change it. Impossible is not a fact. It's an opinion. Impossible is not a declaration. It's a dare. Impossible is potential. Impossible is temporary. Impossible is nothing.”
~ Muhammad Ali